Skip to content
Unigale

Costs & ROI

DG vs BESS: compare the full operating cost

A meaningful DG vs BESS comparison serves the same load for the same hours. This guide explains the inputs behind the website calculator, including what the model includes and what it deliberately leaves out.

By UnigaleUpdated 3 min read

Key takeaway

A lower operating cost is not the same as a positive investment return. Compare installed capital, charging, maintenance and future replacement on a consistent basis.

Define the same duty for both options

Begin with the actual load in kW, not the generator's nameplate kVA. For illustration, a steady 100 kW load requires 100, 200, 300 or 600 kWh of delivered energy for one, two, three or six hours respectively. These figures are simple load-times-duration calculations, not system sizes.

In our calculator, every duration is independently sized. Increasing hours changes both delivered energy and the battery investment; it does not simply multiply savings while leaving the battery unchanged.

Build the diesel baseline from measured records

The model uses the following calculation:

Formula: DG variable cost per kWh = diesel price per litre × fuel use per delivered kWh + variable maintenance per kWh

Then multiply by the delivered energy and operating days. Use measured fuel and output records for the relevant loading conditions. Allocate maintenance on a clearly stated basis rather than assuming all annual maintenance disappears when generator use falls.

The existing DG purchase cost is treated as sunk in this comparison. A new-generator purchase versus a new BESS is a different baseline. Retaining the DG as standby may also retain fixed servicing and compliance costs, which are not credited as automatic savings here.

Account for the full battery pathway

Our planning model includes battery and PCS capital, integration cost, electricity for charging, round-trip losses, auxiliary energy, annual BESS maintenance and an optional future battery-replacement allowance. Battery degradation can leave a later-year energy shortfall; the model assigns that shortfall to DG operation.

It uses a simplified daily duty, not an hourly dispatch optimisation. A complete project study should evaluate site-specific scheduling and multiple sources together. REopt is an example of a planning platform that evaluates the size and operation of integrated energy systems. [1]

Read payback and ROI correctly

Simple payback in this calculator is initial capital divided by first-year operating savings. It does not capture a later replacement expense. If operating savings are not positive, that simple calculation has no positive payback.

Ten-year net benefit subtracts initial capital and modelled replacement spending from cumulative operating savings. ROI divides this net benefit by initial plus replacement capital. NPV discounts annual net cash flows at the entered real discount rate.

Prices are constant in real terms. The model excludes GST, financing, tax effects, subsidies, salvage value, downtime value, grid-export income and separate demand-charge or tariff-shifting benefits. Exclusions are not assumed to be zero in a real project; they are outside this screening calculation.

Test the difficult scenario before the attractive one

We recommend testing fewer operating days, a higher charging rate, lower fuel displacement and higher capital cost. Check whether the battery can actually recharge before the next required discharge. Do not add peak-shifting savings unless the dispatch plan can deliver those savings without compromising the backup duty.

Also separate local combustion emissions from lifecycle environmental impact. Battery operation does not burn diesel at the point of discharge, but charging sources and equipment lifecycle still matter. DG permissions and local safety requirements need their own current review; a financial calculator cannot establish legal compliance.

Compare the 1, 2, 3 and 6-hour scenarios →

Sources

  1. [1]National Laboratory of the Rockies: integrated cost and resilience planning
  2. [2]Unigale calculation methodology

Talk to Our Team

Share your load and how long it needs to run. We'll size a system and send a quote.