Skip to content
Unigale

A comparison you can inspect.

The DG vs BESS tool is an illustrative, ten-year, constant-price planning model.

Compare the same electrical service

Supported energy per day is load (kW) multiplied by duration (hours). Each duration is independently sized; no scenario assumes a fixed battery can deliver unlimited backup. Nominal capacity is the daily energy divided by usable depth of discharge, discharge efficiency and an end-of-life reserve.

Formula: Nominal kWh = (load kW × hours) ÷ (depth of discharge × discharge efficiency × end-of-life reserve)

PCS power is taken as 1.2 × the supported load as an illustrative continuous-power headroom. It is not a motor-starting study or surge guarantee.

Include the relevant costs

The existing DG pathway includes variable diesel fuel and maintenance:

Formula: DG cost per kWh = diesel price × fuel use per kWh + variable maintenance per kWh

The BESS pathway includes battery and PCS capital, integration cost, annual maintenance (as a percentage of capital), charging energy (delivered energy ÷ round-trip efficiency, plus daily auxiliary energy), capacity degradation, any residual DG operation when the aged battery falls short, and the selected battery replacement allowance.

Existing DG purchase cost is treated as sunk. Avoided DG fixed maintenance, avoided generator purchase, financing, tax, GST, subsidies, export income, carbon credits, escalation, salvage value and downtime value are excluded.

Understand the outputs

  • Simple payback is initial capital divided by first-year operating savings, when positive. It excludes later replacement spending.
  • Ten-year net benefit subtracts initial and replacement spending from cumulative operating savings.
  • ROI divides that net benefit by total initial and replacement capital.
  • NPV discounts annual net cash flows at the selected real discount rate.

Check the limitations

Recharge feasibility is only an indicative power/time check. Actual site charging power, solar variability, tariffs, motor inrush, backup reserve and thermal conditions need engineering review.

Fuel consumption is an editable energy-specific average; part-load fuel performance should be measured. The battery is assumed to be charged before the backup event. Round-trip efficiency and discharge efficiency have different roles: charging cost and usable capacity respectively.

Negative economic results remain visible. Selecting no replacement leaves degradation in the model and assigns residual DG running to any shortfall.

Return to the calculator →